Eighteen hundred days of combat, Carl von Clausewitz, and a career in intelligence taught me that the most dangerous leader is the one who is certain he is right.
At eighteen, I learned a lesson no classroom could teach. Reality doesn’t care how confident, careful, or polished you are.
Across roughly 1,800 consecutive days of war, I came to understand the gap between knowing what to do and being able to do it when events turn against you.
Decades later, in Melbourne, I began to question a phrase we have all heard countless times: we learn from our mistakes.
Do we?
If mistakes made us wiser, experienced executives would not repeat decisions that previously damaged their companies.
Entrepreneurs would not persist with failing strategies. Intelligent people maintain valuable relationships, even when wrong.
Perhaps the problem is not the mistakes. Perhaps it is how we think about them.
The nineteenth-century Prussian military theorist Carl von Clausewitz, in his unfinished masterpiece On War, explored three ideas that speak directly to modern leadership: friction, uncertainty, and strategic purpose.
He wrote about warfare, not management. But his observations offer a compelling framework for understanding why organizations fail, why leaders repeat errors, and why winning is not always the same as succeeding.
1.Knowledge is not capability: the power of friction
“Everything in war is basic,” Clausewitz observed, “but the simplest thing is difficult.” He referred to the discrepancy between a plan and its actual outcome as friction. In the military, we studied procedures, rehearsed movements, and prepared for a range of scenarios. Yet what was expected to happen and what happened were never quite the same. Equipment failed. Communications became unreliable. Information arrived late. Circumstances shifted. A simple task became extraordinarily difficult, not because of one catastrophic error, but because many small difficulties accumulated. Business is no different. Consider a company rolling out a new technology platform. The business case is persuasive, the investment is approved, and the timetable is set. Then reality intervenes. Training takes longer than planned. Legacy systems prove incompatible. Data migration stalls. Departments interpret instructions differently. Each problem looks manageable in isolation. Together, they threaten the entire project. When the initiative fails, management typically hunts for a single mistake or culprit. More often the cause is fifty small problems that nobody thought important enough to fix.The greatest danger is not always the obstacle in front of us. It is the accumulation of obstacles we have convinced ourselves are insignificant.
Military training taught me that understanding a procedure is not enough. Repetition, preparation, and practical application are what build the ability to perform under pressure. Companies should heed the distinction. An organization may have excellent procedures, sophisticated technology, and highly educated staff. The question is whether its people can perform when conditions deteriorate. Knowledge must become capability, and capability must be tested against reality.2.Deciding under uncertainty: the myth of perfect information
Clausewitz understood that uncertainty is inseparable from war. In Book I, Chapter 3 of On War, he describes it as a domain in which much of the information on which action depends is obscured. That is an uncomfortable reality for leaders. We rarely have all the information we would like before making an important decision. In combat, waiting for certainty was rarely realistic: information was incomplete, assessments proved wrong, and circumstances changed before a decision could be carried out. Occasionally the cost of doing nothing exceeded the cost of an imperfect decision. My later work in military and diplomatic intelligence reinforced another lesson. Information differs from intelligence, and intelligence differs from certainty. Information must be assessed, sources questioned, and assumptions challenged. Even then, uncertainty remains. Consider the entrepreneur who delays a product launch because one more market study might provide greater confidence, or the executive who defers a difficult call because further reports are due. Sometimes waiting is responsible. Occasionally it is an expensive way of avoiding accountability. The answer is not recklessness. Speed without judgement is dangerous, particularly when safety, large financial commitments, or irreversible consequences are involved. Experienced leaders must distinguish between decisions that warrant more investigation and those where extra information is unlikely to change the outcome. Before any major decision, I believe leaders should ask four questions: What do we know? What are we assuming? What happens if we are wrong? And what will waiting cost us? Experience can sharpen judgment, especially when it is supported by reliable feedback and repeated practice. But it can also entrench faulty assumptions. Twenty years of experience does not necessarily mean twenty years of learning; sometimes it means making the same mistake for twenty years. The difference lies in whether experience has been examined, challenged, and converted into better judgment.3.What should victory accomplish? The risk of winning the wrong battle
Perhaps Clausewitz’s most important strategic insight concerns the link between military action and political purpose. In Book I, Chapter 1, he argued that military action must be understood in relation to the political objectives it serves. For business leaders, the equivalent question is blunt: what will this victory achieve? Imagine an executive who wins an argument with a senior employee. Authority is asserted, and the executive’s interpretation is vindicated. But the employee loses trust in management, communication deteriorates, and, eventually, a valuable colleague resigns. The executive prevailed in the debate. What did the organization gain? Or take a company that meets its quarterly targets by cutting costs, increasing workloads, and deferring essential investment. The KPIs look impressive. But morale erodes, customer confidence slips, and the business becomes less resilient. Was that success? We routinely confuse hitting an immediate objective with achieving something strategically worthwhile. The same logic applies to failure. A company may lose a commercial negotiation yet avoid a financially damaging agreement. An entrepreneur may abandon a failing product before exhausting available capital. A manager may concede an argument and preserve a relationship that later proven invaluable. Judged against the immediate goal, each looks like a loss. Each may be a sound strategy. Occasionally, the costliest error in your career is a battle you won. Some disagreements should be embraced. Some principles are worth defending, even at a cost. The leadership challenge lies in distinguishing between a principle that is worth defending and an ego that is simply seeking victory. Some arguments don’t need to be won, some opportunities don’t deserve investment, and some victories don’t deserve celebration.Why intelligent people keep repeating mistakes
There is another obstacle to learning that deserves greater attention: ego.
In my career in intelligence and corporate investigations, I learned to question information, challenge assumptions, and separate what people believe from what the evidence supports.
Yet people become emotionally invested in their decisions. We defend strategies because we created them.
We dismiss criticism because it threatens our authority.
We explain away inconvenient evidence because accepting it would force us to change. Occasionally we would rather protect our reputation than discover the truth.
The consequences inside organizations are serious. When employees fear punishment for reporting mistakes, critical information never reaches management. When executives treat disagreement as disloyalty, poor decisions go unchallenged.
Encouraging honest reporting does not mean abandoning accountability. Negligence, dishonesty, and repeated disregard for established procedures still warrant consequences. Effective leadership demands both psychological safety and responsibility.
One further distinction matters. A carefully considered decision can produce an unfortunate outcome, and a reckless one can succeed through luck.
Judging decisions solely by results, and you risk rewarding poor judgment and punishing sound behaviour. Genuine learning requires examining the reasoning behind a decision, not just
its outcome.
The real question is not “What did we do wrong?” It is “What made us believe we were right?”
Until we answer that question, we may address the immediate problem but still preserve the flawed thinking that led to it.
From the battlefield to the boardroom
In the military, identifying a mistake was only the beginning. The real value came from examining what happened, understanding why, and changing how we prepared for the next challenge. The same discipline belongs in every organization.
After a failed project, a difficult negotiation or an unexpected setback, leaders should ask four questions: What were we trying to accomplish? What happened? Which assumptions proved wrong? And what will we do differently next time?
The last is the most important. An investigation can produce an excellent report without producing meaningful change.
A company can identify weaknesses without correcting them.
A manager can acknowledge an error without altering their behaviour.
That is not learning. It is repetition accompanied by an explanation.
Business, of course, is not war. Employees are not soldiers, competitors are not enemies, and commercial setbacks should never be equated with the human cost of armed conflict.
But friction, uncertainty, judgement, and strategic purpose matter wherever people make consequential decisions.
War taught me to respect preparation while recognizing its limits. Intelligence work taught me to question information rather than accept it at face value.
Business continues to remind me that experience is valuable only if we remain willing to challenge what we believe.
We cannot eliminate every mistake or anticipate every obstacle. But we can be more disciplined in how we examine failure: spotting small problems before they accumulate, testing assumptions before they harden into convictions, and asking whether the victories we pursue are worth
their consequences.
The greatest danger is sometimes making the right decision.
Occasionally it is becoming so convinced of our experience, intelligence, and authority that we stop questioning our decisions altogether.
We do not become wiser simply by surviving our mistakes. We become wiser when we have the courage to examine them, the humility to question our thinking, and the discipline to
act differently.
So the question every leader should ask is this:
Are we genuinely learning from our mistakes, or simply becoming more experienced at
repeating them?